Mike’s Pizza

Reviews

• Sara S.

  star star star star star 4 June 2026

  I was first introduced to Mike's over five years ago after a date at the comedy club across the street. Little did I know I'd a) move to this 'hood and b) this would become one of my go to spots. Sentimental details aside, Mike's makes a really good, cheap pie.
  
  It's rare I stray from a medium pie with a topping which will set you back 16 bucks. The pie itself is simple and straightforward with a really excellent crust. I'm one of those weirdos who usually ends up with a crust graveyard on my plate, but Mike's is actually worth eating. It's got a nice crunch and chewiness to it.
  
  Some other menu standouts are the garlic knots, minestrone soup, and mozzarella sticks. I was honestly so surprised by how good the minestrone was. It's 4 bucks for a standard side soup serving, but it's filled to the brim with fresh veggies, garlic, and penne. It's perfect if you're not feeling so hot. Although I've tried their calzones and pastas they weren't worth ordering again. Kinda bland and unmemorable to be totally honest.
  
  Mike's has been a neighborhood staple for so long the phone number on their box doesn't even have an area code. As long as they're still around it'll be my go to for no frills slices.

• Marla F.

  star star star star_border star_border 2 June 2026

  Nice and convenient average pizza alert! Mike's is a fine pizza joint and every slice I've had has been pretty good,  although not very memorable.
  
  I do appreciate the array of toppings for slices though. They usually do a few combinations of veggie slices which is super nice! **Cue all Kips Bay vegetarians**
  
  Last night I got the broccoli mushroom slice for $4.50. Other nights I've gotten different veggie combos-- whatever they made that day.
  
  Stop here if you're walking home from work and need to nip that pizza slice craving!

• Maya N.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 31 May 2026

  Overpriced, lame fatty gross crust, skimpy
  On the cheese, fail fail fail on everything that makes a pizza decent. I mean it's hot cheese on crispy bread . Hard to mess Up but they somehow managed to do so. Ratios are all off: super hard and thick crust- literally hard to eat.
  
  The only stars are for semi decent service.

• Jacob R.

  star star star star star 23 May 2026

  Stopped in here to use the bathroom and couldn't resist the pizza! My only regret is not getting more than one piece, it was fresh and very good!

• John E.

  star star star star star_border 13 May 2026

  Is this the best Pizza in NYC? Probably not - but that being said any pizza in NYC is going to be better than most you'll find elsewhere. Mike's is a local by-the-slice place close to the Marcel Hotel (where I was staying during this visit) - I needed a couple of slices because, well, you can't go to NYC without getting at least one slice. They had a deluxe and a regular cheese - I like to try them unadulterated - I think that's the true test. Both were delicious and had a nice amount of mailardization to the ingredients with a bit of sweetness and a super crisp crust - these guys know what they're doing for sure.
  
  Service was fast and good - the place usually has a line. It could probably use a good cleaning, but as pizza goes this is top-notch. The people behind the counter were a bit short on words but otherwise friendly - both times I ate the slices at tables inside.